HRIS Vendor Comparison Template

Organize demo results, requirements, and services in an easy comparison format

Comparing HRIS vendors is more useful when every option is assessed using the same scenario. A template helps record capabilities you have checked and questions that still need discussion. Separate demonstrated facts from users' impressions so the reasons behind the decision are clear.

Apply the same criteria to every option

Define the process, intended users and an example of the expected result before the demo. Present the same requirements to each vendor so different presentation materials do not distort the comparison.

Explain the priority of each criterion. Give essential requirements precedence when comparing results, even if one option offers more additional features.

Record answers separately from evidence

Write down what the vendor says, then the evidence you have seen. If additional configuration is needed, record the conditions and anything still awaiting confirmation.

Use concrete wording, such as “branch report tested.” Avoid general comments such as “good” without explaining what was assessed.

Compare implementation and support coverage

Check who helps with data, setup, training and issues after users start working. Record the support channels and escalation process explained by each vendor.

Read cost details alongside their scope. A price difference alone tells you little if the user numbers, modules or services being compared differ.

Discuss the differences with your team

Review unmet requirements and any additional work needed. Document the reasons for the choice and the information still awaiting confirmation.

Sigma's team helps companies evaluate Sigma HRIS and Forte HRIS with a clear focus. Application quality and support until issues are resolved are part of the discussion from the outset.

An example format you can use

Use this example as a starting point. Copy the table into your working document and adapt its contents, owners, dates and statuses to your company. The entries are illustrative, not findings from an actual company assessment.

HRIS Vendor Comparison Template
CriterionOption A: example notesOption B: example notesNext question or action
Absence requestsComplete workflow demonstratedRequest form demonstratedCheck option B's approval workflow
Branch reportsSample data neededSample data neededUse the same reporting period
MigrationData source scope needs more detailData source scope needs more detailConfirm which data will be migrated
TrainingParticipants not yet identifiedParticipants not yet identifiedUse the same user requirements
SupportSupport contacts explainedAsk about escalationRecord service responsibilities
ProposalScope needs reviewScope needs reviewCompare equivalent coverage

Keeping demo results useful for later comparison

When two vendors demonstrate different processes

The first vendor demonstrates an absence request through to approval, while the second shows only the request form. These presentations do not yet provide equivalent evidence. Ask the second vendor to demonstrate the complete scenario before assessing whether its workflow fits your needs.

Record what has been checked and which questions remain unanswered. If you need weighted criteria, agree on the weights before assigning scores. Numbers without clear definitions can appear objective while still reflecting different reviewers' impressions.

Keep a record of the reasons behind the decision

The final assessment should identify requirements that are met, limitations the company accepts and preparation needed before implementation. These notes help the implementation team understand the choice and avoid assuming that every requirement is already available as standard.

Sigma HRIS supports on premises and private cloud deployment, while Forte HRIS is cloud based. Sigma's team assists with requirements mapping, implementation and ongoing use. Development based on customer feedback and continuing support help sustain application quality over the long term.

Frequently asked questions

Does the template need a scoring system?

No. You can record evidence and status instead. If you use scores, define the criteria first.

How can we compare different demonstrations?

Request the same scenario from each vendor and mark any steps that have not been demonstrated.

Are the vendors in the example table being assessed?

No. The table illustrates how to record findings; it does not assess any particular company.

How should we record costs?

Record the number of users, features, implementation work and support included in each proposal. Compare prices once service coverage is clear.

Who sets the priorities?

The people within your company who understand its operational needs and procurement decisions.

What can we discuss with Sigma?

Process requirements, practical demonstrations, product options, implementation preparation and support arrangements.

Explore more HRIS guides

Discuss your company's HRIS requirements

The Sigma team helps you understand Sigma HRIS and Forte HRIS, prepare for implementation, and use the application with a commitment to support until issues are resolved.

Discuss Your Requirements